Conference Sessions |

 CCT Conference Agenda: Condensed Versionprint friendly version (condensed) | CCT Conference Agenda: Extened Versionprint friendly version (extended) |
CCT Conference Agenda: Condensed VersionVersión para imprimir (condensada)  
June 26 Watch Video June 27 June 28 June 29 June 30

0900–1030:
Opening Session

 

Master of Ceremony: Yadigar Gökalp, Executive Director, SRMP, Turkey

Mevlüt Bilici, General Director for Social Assistance and Solidarity, Turkey

Andrew Vorkink , Turkey Country Director, World Bank

Beşir Atalay, State Minister, Turkey

Recep Tayyip Erdoğan, Prime Minister, Turkey

Key Note: CCTs in the bigger picture of social policy

 

Alain de Janvry, Director, World Development Report 2008, World Bank/University of California at Berkeley
Alain de Janvry - Key Note Conditional Cash Transfer Programs in the Bigger Picture of Social PolicyEnglish
Alain de Janvry - Los Programas de Transferencias en Efectivo Condicionadas en el gran contexto de la Política SocialEspañol

0900–1000
What have we learned about the impacts of CCT?

 

Chair: Santiago Levy, formerly with the Mexican Social Security Institute

Conditional Cash Transfer Programs:
Reviewing the Evidence

 

Norbert Schady, World Bank
Norbert Schady - Conditional Cash Transfer Programs: Reviewing the EvidenceEnglish
Norbert Schady - Programas de transferencia en efectivo condicionadas: repaso de la información disponibleEspañol

1000–1100

Reflection on the dilemma of whether to condition: A panel discussion

 

Chair: Ariel Fiszbein, World Bank

Debate

 

For CCT, Miguel Székeley, formerly with Mexican Ministry of Finance
Miguel Székeley - To Condition… Or Not to ConditionEnglish
Norbert Schady - Programas de transferencia en efectivo condicionadas: repaso de la información disponibleEspañol

Against CCT, Michael Samson, Economic Policy Research Institute, South Africa
Michael Samson - The Case for Unconditional Social TransfersEnglish
Norbert Schady - Programas de transferencia en efectivo condicionadas: repaso de la información disponibleEspañol

Further Reflection:
Michael Samson - The Case for Unconditional Social Transfers"When to use a CCT vs. CT Approach?"
Alain de Janvry and Elisabeth Sadoulet, World Bank/University of California at Berkley

 

FIELD TRIP
Field Trip Program DescriptionField Trip Program Description

 

Site 1: IZNIK (BURSA-YALOVA)

Site 2: EDIRNE (EDIRNE)

Site 3: EMİNONU (ISTANBUL)

Site 4: GAZİOSMANPASA (ISTANBUL)

Site 5: BAĞCILAR (ISTANBUL)

Site 6: KADIKOY (ISTANBUL)

Site 7: KARTAL (ISTANBUL)

Site 8: PENDIK (ISTANBUL)

Site 9: UMRANİYE (ISTANBUL)

 

 

 

0900–1030
PARALLEL SESSIONS

Basic Operations

Targeting: implementation mechanisms for means and proxy means tests: Lessons from Latin America


Moderator:
Emil Tesliuc, World Bank
K. Lindert and T. Castañeda - Implementation mechanisms for means and proxy means tested programsEnglish
K. Lindert and T. Castañeda - Implementación de mecanismos para los programas usando proxy means test Experiencias de América LatinaEspañol

Key Reading:
English

Management Function Governance in CCTs: complaints resolution and appeals

Moderator:
Sandor Sipos, World Bank
Governance in CCTs: Complaints Resolution and AppealsEnglish
Sandor Sipos - Gobernabilidad en las CCT: solución de reclamos y apelacionesEspañol

Muge Nisanci, Turkey
 Complaints Resolution and Appeals: Case of Turkish CCTEnglish
Español

Ecuador
Complaints Resolution and Appeals: Case of Turkish CCTEnglish
Programa de Protección Social: EcuadorEspañol

Susana Gamez, Domican Republic
English
Programa Solidaridad. República DominicanaEspañol
Institutional Arrangement

Institutions for implementing CCTs

Moderator:
Andrea Vermehren, World Bank
Andrea Vermehren and Foluso Okunmadewa - Institutional Arrangements for Cash Transfer ProgramsEnglish
Andrea Vermehren and Foluso Okunmadewa - Acuerdos Institucionales para los Programas de Transferencias en EfectivoEspañol

Brig. Muhammad Sarafraz, Pakistan
Institutional Arrangements – CT/CCT in PakistanEnglish
Andrea Vermehren and Foluso Okunmadewa - Acuerdos Institucionales para los Programas de Transferencias en EfectivoEspañol

Paul Chipeta, Malawi
Institutional Arrangements – CT/CCT in PakistanEnglish
Andrea Vermehren and Foluso Okunmadewa - Acuerdos Institucionales para los Programas de Transferencias en EfectivoEspañol

Beyond Basic Health & Education How to include nutrition/ ECD

Moderator:
Alessandra Marini, World Bank
Alessandra Marini - Including Nutrition and Early Childhood Development (ECD)English
Alessandra Marini - Incluyendo la Nutrición y estimulación temprana en la infancia (ETI)Español

Lynette M Neufeld, Mexico
Nutrition in the Oportunidades Conditional Cash Transfer Program: Strengths and challengesEnglish
Alessandra Marini - Incluyendo la Nutrición y estimulación temprana en la infancia (ETI)Español

Faith D. Innerarity,
Jamaica
Incorporating Early Childhood Development in Conditional Cash Transfer Programs: The Jamaican ExperienceEnglish
Alessandra Marini - Incluyendo la Nutrición y estimulación temprana en la infancia (ETI)Español

Background reading:
Incorporating Early Childhood Development in Conditional Cash Transfer Programs: The Jamaican ExperienceEnglish

0900–1030
PARALLEL SESSIONS

Basic Operations

Monitoring compliance with conditionalities

Moderator:
Cornelia Tesliuc, World Bank
Cornelia Tesliuc - Monitoring compliance with conditionalityEnglish
Cornelia Tesliuc - Control del cumplimiento de condicionalidadesEspañol

María Concepción Steta
MarÍa Conceptión Steta - Oportunidades: Monitoring ConditionalitiesEnglish
Cornelia Tesliuc - Control del cumplimiento de condicionalidadesEspañol

Colette Roberts Risden
Colette Roberts Risden - Monitoring Performance:JamaicaEnglish
Colette Roberts Risden - Seguimiento del desempeño:JamaicaEspañol
Management Function Monitoring performance

Moderator:
Emil Tesliuc, World Bank
Emil D. Tesliuc - Using Monitoring to Improve the Performance of SSN ProgramsEnglish
Emil D Tesliuc & Banco Mundia - Uso del seguimiento para mejorar el desempeño de los programas de SSNEspañol

Rômulo Paes de Sousa
Rômulo Paes Da Sousa - The Bolsa Familia Monitoring: The experience of BrazilEnglish
Emil D Tesliuc & Banco Mundia - Uso del seguimiento para mejorar el desempeño de los programas de SSNEspañol

Handout:
Rômulo Paes Da Sousa - The Bolsa Familia Monitoring: The experience of BrazilEnglish
Emil D Tesliuc & Banco Mundia - Uso del seguimiento para mejorar el desempeño de los programas de SSNEspañol

Institutional Arrangement

Improving health & education services

Moderator:
Ferdinando Regalia, IADB
Rômulo Paes Da Sousa - The Bolsa Familia Monitoring: The experience of BrazilEnglish
Emil D Tesliuc & Banco Mundia - Uso del seguimiento para mejorar el desempeño de los programas de SSNEspañol

Leslie Castro
Rômulo Paes Da Sousa - The Bolsa Familia Monitoring: The experience of BrazilEnglish
Emil D Tesliuc & Banco Mundia - Uso del seguimiento para mejorar el desempeño de los programas de SSNEspañol

María Concepción Steta
Rômulo Paes Da Sousa - The Bolsa Familia Monitoring: The experience of BrazilEnglish
Emil D Tesliuc & Banco Mundia - Uso del seguimiento para mejorar el desempeño de los programas de SSNEspañol
Beyond Basic Health & Education

Special target groups (indigenous, disabled, OVC, etc.)

Moderator:
Jeanine Braithwaite, World Bank
Jeanine Braithwaite - Disabled People in CCT ProgramsEnglish
Emil D Tesliuc & Banco Mundia - Uso del seguimiento para mejorar el desempeño de los programas de SSNEspañol

Nelson Gutiérrez
Nelson GutiérrezEnglish
Nelson GutiérrezEspañol

Francisco Ayala
Francisco AyalaEnglish
Español

Kenya
Francisco AyalaEnglish
Español

1030–1100 Coffee/Tea Break 1030–1100 Coffee/Tea Break

1100–1230
Conditional Cash Transfers in Turkey

 

Chair: John Innes,World Bank

Description of the program
Yadigar Gökalp, SRMP, Turkey
Yadigar Gökalp - CONDITIONAL CASH TRANSFERS IN TURKEYEnglish
Yadigar Gökalp - TRANSFERENCIAS EN EFECTIVO CONDICIONADAS EN TURQUÍAEspañol

Evaluating the Conditional Cash Transfer Program in Turkey
Akhter Ahmed, International Food Policy Research Institute

Yadigar Gökalp - CONDITIONAL CASH TRANSFERS IN TURKEYEnglish
Yadigar Gökalp - TRANSFERENCIAS EN EFECTIVO CONDICIONADAS EN TURQUÍAEspañol


Discussant: Lila Pieters, UNICEF Turkey

1130–1230
Getting the content right in CCT interventions: Linking objectives with program design (Building human capital, reducing poverty, and promoting inclusion)

 

Chair: Susana Gamez - Social Cabinet of the Presidency, Dominican Republic

Age group 0-5: standard pre-natal/immunization services, nutrition, ECD, John Hoddinott, IFPRI
John Hoddinott - Conditional Cash Transfers for Pre-school ChildrenEnglish
John Hoddinott - Transferencias en Efectivo Condicionadas para Niños pre-escolaresEspañol

Discussant: Cecilia Gallardo, The Presidency, El Salvador

 

1100–1230
PARALLEL SESSIONS

Basic Operations

Targeting: community-based methods

Moderator:
Dr. Matthias Rompel, GTZ

Jean Hamonga, Zambia
Jean Hamonga - Community-based TargetingEnglish
Jean Hamonga - Focalización Basada en la Comunidad: Estudio de caso ZambiaEspañol

Julian Hansen, GTZ
Developing Harmonised Criteria for Identification of Poor Households in CambodiaEnglish
Español

English
English

Selected Further Reading:
English
Developing Harmonised Criteria for Identification of Poor Households in CambodiaEnglish
English
English
Management Function Governance Risks: Controls and Accountability

Moderator:
David Warren, World Bank
David Warren - Governance Risks: Controls and AccountabilityEnglish
David Warren - Riesgos de Gobernación:Español
Institutional Arrangement Scaling up CCT: from pilot to large scale
Watch Video Watch Video

Moderator:
Ferdinando Regalia, IADB
David Warren - Governance Risks: Controls and AccountabilityEnglish
David Warren - Riesgos de Gobernación:Español

Cecilia Gallardo
David Warren - Governance Risks: Controls and AccountabilityEnglish
David Warren - Riesgos de Gobernación:Español
Beyond Basic Health & Education

Addressing the needs of Young people through CCTs

Moderator:
Cristobal Ridao-Cano, World Bank
Cristobal Ridao-Cano - Addressing the needs of youngEnglish
David Warren - Riesgos de Gobernación:Español

Santiago Levy
Cristobal Ridao-Cano - Addressing the needs of youngEnglish
David Warren - Riesgos de Gobernación:Español

1100–1230
PARALLEL SESSIONS

Basic Operations

Payment

Moderator:
Carlo del Ninno, World Bank
Carlo del Ninno and Francisco Ayala - Basic Operations: PaymentsEnglish
Español


Management Function Program evaluation

Moderator:
Emil Tesliuc, World Bank
English
Español
Institutional Arrangement Linking CCT to other services

Moderator:
Christine Weigand, World Bank
English
Español

Elizabeth Flores
English
Español
Beyond Basic Health & Education Empowerment and social cohesion

Moderator:
Michelle Adato, IFPRI
English
Español

Rita Combariza, Colombia
English
Español
1230–1430 Lunch Break 1230–1400 Lunch Break

1430–1600
CCTs in middle income countries: Evolution & new challenges

 

Chair: Nora Lustig, UNDP

Country Examples

 

Mexico, Rogelio Gomez-Hermosillo, Ministry of Social Development
English
Rogelio Gomez-Hermosillo - Oportunidades: El Programa de Desarollo Humano de México Español

Brazil, Jean Marc Mutzig, Ministry of Social Development and Hunger Alleviation
Jean Marc Mutzig - The Bolsa Família Grants English
Jean Marc Mutzig - El Programa Bolsa FamiliaEspañol

South Africa, Daniel Plaatjies, South African Social Security Agency
Daniel Plaatjies - Conditional Cash Transfer Programs in South AfricaEnglish
Daniel Plaatjies - Programas de Transferencias en EfectivoEspañol

Linda Richter, Human Sciences Research Council
Linda Richter - Going to scale: South AfricaEnglish
Linda Richter - El ir a Escalar (Going to scale): SudáfricaEspañol

1430–1630
(Getting the content right - continued)

 

Chair: Faith D. Innerarity, Ministry of Labor and Social Security, Jamaica

Age group 6-21: schooling, school health, and risky behaviors, Emmanuel Jimenez, World Bank
Emmanuel Jimenez - Conditional Cash Transfers for School Age Children and YouthEnglish
Emmanuel Jimenez - Transferencias en Efectivo Condicionadas (CCT) para niños en edad escolar y juventudEspañol

Discussant: Rita Combariza, Accion Social- Presidencia de La República, Colombia
Emmanuel Jimenez - Conditional Cash Transfers for School Age Children and YouthEnglish
Emmanuel Jimenez - Transferencias en Efectivo Condicionadas (CCT) para niños en edad escolar y juventudEspañol

Age group 21+: links to services to increase family income in the short run- micro-credit, savings, literacy, training, Patricia Jara, Sistema de Protección Social
Emmanuel Jimenez - Conditional Cash Transfers for School Age Children and YouthEnglish
Patricia Jara - Enlaces a servicios para mejorar el ingreso familiar en el corto plazoEspañol

Discussant: Elizabeth Flores, formerly with Programa de Protección Social, Ecuador

1400–1630
Managing and monitoring CCTs: Paper and pencil or ICT?

Overview: Carlo del Ninno (World Bank)
Carlo del Ninno, Gorra Data, & Francisco Ayala - Managing and monitoring CCTs: Paper and pencil or ICT? Overview English
David Warren - Riesgos de Gobernación:Español

Francisco Ayala (Consultant)
Carlo del Ninno, Gorra Data, & Francisco Ayala - Managing and monitoring CCTs: Paper and pencil or ICT? Overview English
David Warren - Riesgos de Gobernación:Español

Gora Datta (Cal2Cal)
Gora Datta - The Dream: a smooth and efficient CCT Possible uses of ICTEnglish
Gora Datta - El Sueño: un uniforme y eficiente Programa de Transferencia en Efectivo Condicionadas (CCT Programs) Posible usos de ICTEspañol

Panel

 

Internet-based (Turkey),
Muge Nisanci SRMP, Turkey
Muge Nisanci - Use of ICTs in CCT Programs - TurkeyEnglish
Muge Nisanci - El Uso de las Tecnologías de la Información (ICTs) en los Programas de Transferencias en Efectivo Condicionadas (CCT) - TurquíaEspañol

Paper-based (Bangladesh), Shaikh Ahmed, University of Dhaka
Shaikh Ahmed - Implementing and Monitoring CCT using Paper and PencilEnglish
Shaikh Ahmed - Implementando y Monitoreando las transferencias en efectivo condicionadas (CCT). Utilizando Papel y LápizEspañol

Further Reading:
Shaikh Ahmed - Implementing and Monitoring CCT using Paper and PencilEnglish
Shaikh Ahmed - Implementing and Monitoring CCT using Paper and PencilEnglish

 

 

1400–1530
PARALLEL SESSIONS

The way ahead: application of CCT in different contexts
(based on lessons learned during this conference)

CCT in post-conflict situations

Moderator:
Giuseppe Zampaglione, World Bank
English
Español

Francisco Ayala
English
Español

Henda Lucia Ducados,
Angola
English
Español

Diego Molano, Colombia
English
Español

Syl Fannah, Sierra Leone
English
Español

Tahani Madhoun, Palestine
English
Español
CCT in low income/low capacity contexts

Moderator:
Marito Garcia, World Bank
English
Español
Differential approaches to CCTs in Urban and Rural areas

Moderator:
Ana Revenga and Caridad Araujo, World Bank
English
Español

Incorporating Risk Management in CCT Design

Moderator:
Renos Vakis, World Bank
English
Español

Elisabeth Sadoulet
English
Español

Theresa Suaso
English
Español

Further Reading:
English
1600–1630 Coffee/Tea Break 1600–1630 Coffee/Tea Break

1630–1800
CCTs in low income countries: Applicability & challenges

 

Chair: Stephen Kidd, DFID

Country Examples

 

Bangladesh: Akhter Ahmed, International Food Policy Research Institute
Akhtar Ahmed - Conditional Cash and Food Transfer Programs for Education in BangladeshEnglish
Akhtar Ahmed - Programas de transferencias condicionadas en efectivo y alimentos por educación en BangladeshEspañol

Nicaragua: Leslie Castro, Ministry of the Family
Akhtar Ahmed - Conditional Cash and Food Transfer Programs for Education in BangladeshEnglish
Akhtar Ahmed - Programas de transferencias condicionadas en efectivo y alimentos por educación en BangladeshEspañol

Kenya: Ahmed Hussein, Ministry of Home Affairs
Ahmed Hussein - Conditional Cash Transfers in low income countries: Applicability and Challenges – KenyaEnglish
Akhtar Ahmed - Programas de transferencias condicionadas en efectivo y alimentos por educación en BangladeshEspañol

1630–1800
POSTER FAIR

 

Argentina
Ciudadania Portena - con todo derecho

Brazil
Programa Bolsa Familia

Cambodia
JFPR

Colombia
Programa Familias en Accion

Dominican Republic
Programa Solidaridad

Ecuador
Bono de Desarollo Humano Human Development Voucher

Honduras
Programa de Asignacion Familiar PRAF

Jamaica
Program of Advancement through Health and Education (PATH)

Madagascar
National Relief Council

Malawi
Public Works CCT

Mexico
Programa de Desarrollo Humano Oprtunidades

Nicaragua
Red de Protección Social

South Africa
Regional Hunger and Vulnerability Program (RHVP)

South Africa
Child Support Grant

Tanzania (Save the Children)
Save the Children UK
(Research on Cash Transfers)


Uganda
Community-led HIV/AIDS Initiatives of the Uganda HIV/AIDS Control Project – The Map of Uganda
Uganda

UK (DFID)
Managing Social Transfers

Uruguay
Plan de Atencion Nacional a la Emergencia

Zambia (CARE International)
Chipata Urban CCT Project

 

1630–1800
ICT FAIR

Firm 1: ACCOR Services
  ACCOR Services Public Social Programs

Firm 2: Internet Society— Bulgaria
  Enhancing service delivery, social protection and livelihood support for the poor through ICT

Firm 3: JP Morgan Chase Bank
  JPMorgan Electronic Financial Services

Firm 4: National Database & Registration Authority (NADRA) Pakistan

  National Database & Registration Authority (NADRA)

Firm 5: Sodexho Pass International
  Sodexho Pass Assistance Programs for Government

Firm 6: INNOVA IT Solutions Turkey
  CCT Project in Turkey Developed by INNOVA

Firm 7: Visa International

  Visa card-based Conditional Cash Transfer programs

Firm 8: Ministry of SOCIAL Development and Fight against Hunger

 

- Social Information Matrix
- Ministry of Social Development and Fight against Hunger – Brazil

Firm 9: Mexico TBD

  TBA

Firm 10: WFP
  CLS- ARGOS: Monitoring the progress in development using satellite technology

Firm 11: Net-1 U.E.D.S. Technologies, Inc
  Universal Electronic Payment System

1545–1700
Closing session: Lessons learned and the way forward

  Moderators:
Margaret Grosh and Azedine Ouerghi, World Bank
 


Panel of selected participants

I. The way forward for groups of countries

 

Santiago Levy, formerly with the Mexican Social Security Institute
Ahmed Hussein, Ministry of Home Affairs, Kenya
Christine Weigand,World Bank
Norbert Schady - Conditional Cash Transfer Programs: Reviewing the EvidenceEnglish
Norbert Schady - Conditional Cash Transfer Programs: Reviewing the EvidenceEspañol

II. Specific country experiences

 

Bambang Widianto, Indonesia Bappenas, Indonesia
Yadigar Gökalp, Social Risk Mitigation Project, Turkey
Norbert Schady - Conditional Cash Transfer Programs: Reviewing the Evidence